i didn't want to derail the thread so i'm leaving this here instead
basically i think "its an rpg made in japan so its a jrpg" is a bit simplistic. genres arent *really* defined by one or two gameplay mechanics, its really much moreso about the REASONS why you play, the emotions it inspires, etc. extra credits explains this better than i could, but essentially the appeal of dark souls is entirely different from a jrpg, so i dont really consider it one. it is a bit arbitrary/anal to care THAT much about classification, but its not entirely a dumb distinction given that jrpg and wrpg are essentially two separate genres. notice that its the only time where a genre is given a separate label due to the place where it's made. we dont talk about "american platformers" or "japanese platformers" as if they're somehow fundamentally different depending on where they're made, just for an example.
basically i think "its an rpg made in japan so its a jrpg" is a bit simplistic. genres arent *really* defined by one or two gameplay mechanics, its really much moreso about the REASONS why you play, the emotions it inspires, etc. extra credits explains this better than i could, but essentially the appeal of dark souls is entirely different from a jrpg, so i dont really consider it one. it is a bit arbitrary/anal to care THAT much about classification, but its not entirely a dumb distinction given that jrpg and wrpg are essentially two separate genres. notice that its the only time where a genre is given a separate label due to the place where it's made. we dont talk about "american platformers" or "japanese platformers" as if they're somehow fundamentally different depending on where they're made, just for an example.